|
Note: Over the next 3 weeks, we'll
be looking at the realities of doing business over the Net. This week,
we'll be looking at the big picture of e-commerce and e-business, trying
to draw some perspective from between the frenzied hype of one year ago
and the unwarranted doom and gloom that pervades the sector today. Next
week, we'll focus in more specifically on your options for marketing on
the web. Finally, in the third week, we'll zoom in even more and look at
your effective strategies on how to use search engines in your
e-marketing.
In November 1999, if you were to listen to the hyperbole streaming from
Wall Street, the world was on the eve of an unprecedented revolution. We
were all prepared to lock ourselves away in our homes and live
vicariously through the click of a mouse. We were going to buy
everything from dog food to boxer shorts online, summarily tossing away
hundreds of years of ingrained consumer behavior and embrace the new god
of e-commerce, no questions asked.
Today, one year later, the digital landscape is littered with the
mangled remains of dot-gones. The once mighty dreams of investors who
threw millions at questionable enterprises, hoping to stake a claim in
the new online Eldorado, have come crashing back to earth. Now, the Wall
Street wisdom takes on a different tone. Steer away from the technology
sector, avoid dot coms at all costs, move to traditional value stocks.
B2C (business to consumer e-commerce for the un-digitized) is dead! Long
live bricks and mortar!
What's the reality? Where, between these two extremes, does the real
promise of e-business lie? In my opinion, it wasn't the vision of the
early site owners that was off base. It was the timing. E-commerce was
ready for us. We just weren't ready for it.
Suppose They Built a Store and Nobody Came?
Let's imagine that someone built a new store. This store was designed to
revolutionize the way people shopped. It had an unlimited inventory. It
carried absolutely everything! Secondly, with the revolutionary design
of the store, every single item was just two steps away. You didn't have
to search for items, you just said what you were looking for and the
items would magically appear right in front of you. The store would even
remember what you shopped for last time and ask you if you wanted the
same thing when you entered the store. Want more information about an
item? No problem. Just ask and you'll be given a binder full of
information, including specs, reviews and consumer reports. And the
whole store was totally automated. It didn't require any staff on the
floor or behind the check out counter. Best of all, anyone in the world
could shop in this store. All it required was a little $2000 transporter
pod in your home and you could be in the store in seconds.
There were a few drawbacks in this store, however. First, you couldn't
actually touch or see the product. All you could do is see a little
picture and read about it. Secondly, the people who owned the store had
most of the stock priced the same or higher than it was at the little
store you've always shopped at. And finally, you couldn't take what you
bought home with you. It would be delivered to your home in anywhere
from a day or two to 3 months.
Would you suddenly stop shopping the way you have all your life and go
only to the new store? Probably not. Does that mean the new store is a
bad idea? No. It really does revolutionize shopping and offer an
incredible business model. It needs a few adjustments, and, more
importantly, we have to get used to it. That's all. It's not the vision
behind the store that's faulty. It's the fact that we haven't taken into
account human nature. Like the Titanic, our society can't be steered
onto a new course quickly. But once we are on that new course, there's
no turning back.
Why Haven't We Shopped Online?
So, what is the number one reason why we don't shop more online? Is it
because we don't trust the technology? Are we concerned about security?
Is the lack of instant gratification the answer? Or is it that we're not
prepared to buy something we can't touch and feel? No to all of the
above. The number one barrier to shopping online in North America is
price. Over 65% of all consumers feel they're not getting the best price
online.
Rather than take advantage of the most efficient business to consumer
model ever devised to pass along significant savings to the consumer,
many sites offer items for the same price or even higher than
traditional retail locations. There's a number of reasons why, but the
fact is, people will shop online if they can save money. Will they fire
up the modem to pay more? Not likely.
Take the airlines, for example. Early on, airlines realized the Net
offered them a perfect way to liquidate unused inventory. Each week,
most airlines offer deeply discounted last minute web specials on under
booked flights. The program has been a tremendous success. Airline
tickets are now one of the most purchased consumer items on the
Internet. Occupancy on flights has risen dramatically. Remember the last
time you took a half empty flight somewhere? Me neither.
At some point, more e-tailers are going to have to take advantage of
central warehousing, bulk buying and more efficient business models to
pass along real savings to the consumer. When that happens, we'll buy.
The B2B Revolution
Unlike business to consumer e-commerce, which hasn't lived up to
expectations, business to business e-commerce is undergoing dramatic and
consistent growth. US business trade over the net was $109 billion in
1999, according to Forrester Research. They project it to reach $250
billion in 2000. More and more large organizations are moving to
exclusive net based purchasing program, taking advantage of the inherent
administrative and cost saving benefits.
So, why the difference? Three reasons. First of all, on large scales,
shopping on the Internet is much more convenient and efficient.
Secondly, for business purchases, the emotional component is removed.
The purchase isn't for us, it's for the company. The need to look, touch
and assess the purchase isn't there to the same extent. And finally, in
business to business, there's not the same retail distribution chain to
deal with. Often, the purchase is between the manufacturer and the end
consumer. The manufacturer can pass along the savings that result from a
more efficient delivery model without worrying about upsetting
distributors and wholesalers.
What's the Future Hold?
Make no mistake about it. The internet is going to change the way we do
everything. And that includes shopping. The IDC estimates the world
internet economy will hit $1 trillion by 2001.
The technology market sector has had a very difficult past 8 months, but
to ignore it would be the same as ignoring the industrial or
manufacturing revolutions. What if you had the chance to invest in the
ground floor of Ford? Everybody laughed and told you the horseless
carriage won't amount to anything. You, however, saw the promise in the
noisy, smoke belching, unreliable contraptions. Who would be laughing
today? The trick is picking the right horseless carriage to put your
money on.
The healthiest thing to do is ignore the past year. Forget the hype and
the ridiculous investing frenzy that occurred, where companies with
nothing more than a half baked idea suddenly became worth billions
overnight. That bubble had to burst, and burst it did. More blood shed
will occur and more dot coms will disappear from sight, but it's not
because the sector is dead, it's because the dot com's business model
and it's forecast of the available market was faulty to begin with. The
pendulum has swung back and it's my belief that the correction is over.
Now, in a more realistic, healthier climate comes the real opportunity
to take part in a true revolution. It won't happen overnight, but the
effects will be more profound than anything we've ever experienced
before. |